
Yes, friends our arduous odyssey through Spring Training is about to come to a close.
The Giants had a disappointing 2006. They had expected to be contenders, bolstered by a strong veteran pitching staff. They were in first place in July 23rd but stretches of 3-16 (late July-early Aug) and 2-13 (last Sept) crippled their playoff chances. They limped to the end of the season with a 76-85 record, 3rd place in the NL west.
Starting Pitching
The Giants broke into the piggy bank with reckless abandon to improve their pitching staff. They signed former A’s starter Barry Zito to a 7 year $126 million contract, the richest for a pitcher in baseball history. Is Zito worth all of that money? No. Even though he has never been able to recreate his 2002 Cy Young season, he is still a good pitcher. He was a consistent performer for the As, winning about 15 games, posting an ERA under 4 and not missing a start. The hiccups from this move should be minimal, as he doesn’t even have to leave his apartment. He will benefit from softer NL lineups and no designated hitter. He should have a great year.
Matt Cain, at just 22 years old, will begin his sophomore campaign after a very good rookie year (13-12 4.15 ERA). Most scouts and pundits believe that he will eventually emerge as the ace of the Giants’ staff, possibly even this season.
Longtime Cardinal Matt Morris should be the #3 starter. The veteran is no longer a top of the rotation guy. He was a bit disappointing last year (10-15 4.98 ERA). However, he can still be a decent and durable veteran arm. His inconsistency should worry the Giants, he had a great June and an OK August but had a terrible rest of the season. He also had an ERA that rose by over a run when leaving the spacious confines at home.
26 year-old Noah Lowry will hold down the #4 spot. He was never a highly touted prospect, but had shown some promise in his first year and a half with one of the league’s best changeups (19-13 record with an ERA under 4.00). However, last year he was only 7-10 and his ERA skyrocketed to 4.72.
Veteran Russ Ortiz will try to cement his place in the rotation, but he has a combined 5-19 record with an ERA over 7 since 2005. With youngster Jonathan Sanchez, who showed a tremendous amount of potential last season, breathing down his neck, his leash should be very short.
They have a very good top two in the rotation. However, there are question marks about the back. Even if the plusses outweigh the minuses, it probably will not give them a decisive advantage over the other three contenders.
Bullpen
The bullpen is a bit of an enigma right now for the Giants. Armando Benitez, whom they hope will stay healthy, should be the closer. His last fully healthy season was in 2004 where he was dominant for the Marlins, with an ERA of 1.29 and converting 47-51 save opportunities. However, he has only converted 36 of 48 opportunities in two seasons in San Francisco and has lingering doubts about his makeup, with disappointing meltdowns with both New York clubs.
The rest of the bullpen is a giant mess. Most of their veteran relievers had serious off years last year, and no one has pitched well enough, as of yet, this Spring to even cement their place on the roster. The opportunities to improve the situation, with few middle relievers available and at great cost, appear to be slim and none. The Giants will have to keep their fingers crossed.
Lineup
The Giants will have their age-old problem. They will live and die by the bat of Barry Bonds. If his knee is healthy, he is still a bat to be feared as he chases Hank Aaaron’s home run recoord. If not, this lineup is in trouble.
This theoretically would have been a great lineup, like 8 years ago. Rich Aurillia and Ray Durham both experinced vintage years last year hitting at or near .300 and surpassing 20 HR. Other veterans like Randy Winn, Pedro Feliz, and newly acquired Benji Molina should contribute, but it won’t be enough to protect Bonds and make it a particularly productive lineup.
Scuttlebutt
Barry…Barry
There will be two stories that dominate the Giants’ headlines for the season. The first is obviously Barry Bonds. The Balco Bomber will simultaneously be chasing Hank Aaron’s record and, at the same time, face on ongoing witch-hunt from the federal government, because obviously he was the only player using steroids!
The second will be Barry Zito and whether he can live up to the disgusting contract San Francisco gave him, all of it guranteed. This will be the pressing issue of the franchise for the next decade. If Zito turns out to be a bust, it may cripple the ability of the Giants to contend well into the 2010s.
Outlook: Ehhh
The Giants potentially have a good rotation, but their bullpen looks like rubbish at the moment and their lineup, though certainly having a lot of experience, will be mediocre at best. In the Central they might have a shot, but there are three better teams in the West and they shouldn’t be a factor.